Ryan Miller
We are in a trade war that rewards fund managers who position and not panic. So we position your fund to be ready, not rattled before the next economic devastation even has a chance to land. So by the end of this, you're gonna know what this trade war does next, why, and where the money goes. Not what it did, but what it does next. Because this has happened before. Four times in a hundred years. Two economies this tied together went into a tariff war. It ran the same way every single time. Here's the pattern and the move that came out of it.
Ryan Miller
So before we dive in, just a quick disclaimer. This episode is for entertainment purposes only. Nothing in this episode is legal, financial, tax, or investment advice. Be sure to do your own research with qualified professionals before taking any action from this show or otherwise. Now, with that said, let's dive in.
Ryan Miller
Here's where the trade war stands right now. On July 20th, the White House used a law from 1930 called Section 338. No president had ever used it. It put a 50% tariff on about $20 billion of Canadian goods, and 19 of that is cars and trucks. It started August 19th. The free trade deal gives no exemption. It stacks on top of everything else that's already there. So what happened? Well, Canada answered on September 8th, 15, 25, and 50% on nearly $20 billion of American goods. Things like dairy, farm equipment, steel appliances, paper, electronics. Canada's finance minister said it plainly. Dollar for dollar, rate for rate. And two other things are live at the same time. On July 1st Washington refused to renew the north American trade deal as it is written. It now gets reviewed every single year until it expires in 2036. And about $100 billion of older tariffs, the ones the Supreme Court threw out in February, are still owed back to the companies that paid them. A court and a customs computer system decide when that money even moves. So that is on the board. 50% on cars going south, 50% on farm gear going north. A trade deal on a one-year leash. And $100 billion of refunds are still stuck in who knows where.
Ryan Miller
Now, why is this trade war happening? Well, to understand why, you have to figure out what comes next. Start with the law. See, in February, the Supreme Court said the emergency powers law could not be used for tariffs of any size. That killed the tool the 2025 tariffs were built on. Section 338 is the replacement. It is a law about countries that discriminate against American trade, and it has no dollar cap and no time limit. So, in plain English, the old tariff tool broke, so they pulled a bigger one off the shelf. That is why this round is 50% and not 10. Then there's the calendar. See, the North American deal goes to review every July 1st from here to 2036. A 50% tariff on cars is leveraged sitting on the table before every one of those reviews. So my read, and I will call it a hypothesis, is that the tariff is a negotiating position first and a revenue tool second. And that matters because negotiating positions, they do get traded away. Revenue tools, they do not.
Ryan Miller
Then the counter list. Look at what Canada picked dairy, farm equipment, not oil, not lumber. Those are the goods that come from the states that decide American elections. Canada did the same thing in 1930. The American tariff went up, and the Canadian Parliament matched it inside the year. That is the retaliation playbook. And it is 100 years old. You aim at the politics, not the economy. And under all of it, the money is already moving. Canada's biggest pension fund has $793 billion, and 47% of it sits in the United States. That is $373 billion. Every quarter it reports where the next dollar went, when a trade war starts. That dollar starts to look for a home. Not all at once, but a point at a time. And a point is billions in this case. That is the quietest number on the board, and that is the one that tells you the most, because pension money does not read headlines, it reads risk. So why is it happening?
Ryan Miller
Well, a broken tool got replaced by a bigger, badder one. A treaty review put leverage on the table every single year. And the other side is aiming at the voters. Hold those three because the pattern is built on top of all of that. And here's the part of the trade war that makes you money. Typically, when two economies this tied together go into a tariff war, four things can happen in order every time. I have four cases in a hundred years that they all rhyme. So case one, 1930, Smoot Holly, the highest American tariffs in history. Canada matched them the same year. Between 1929 and 32, American imports from Europe fell more than 70%, and exports fell more than 65%. World trade fell more than 60% by 1934. Then there's case two, 1981, Japanese cars. I remember studying this one in grad school. Washington capped Japanese imports at 1.68 million cars a year. Within 10 years, every major Japanese car maker built a plant in America, eight new assembly plants, more than 300 new production facilities, $25 billion of foreign money in today's dollars. And car prices went up 8% for the American buyer. Then there's case three. 2018, China, tariffs on hundreds of billions of dollars of Chinese goods. China's share of American imports fell 22% to 14. Mexico picked up two points. Canada picked up one. And here's the part the headlines miss. The Fed found that the countries America switched to were buying more from China in exactly the goods America stopped buying from China. The reroute was half a move and half a relabel. Remember that when a Canadian parts maker tells you it moved to Mexico, and Washington wrote $23 billion of checks to American farmers in two years to cover that retaliation. Remember that. Then there's case four, right next door, softwood lumber, 40 years of duty, sitting around 35% last summer. Canadian lumber production is down 26% since 2017. British Columbia, or BC, as we say in Canada, is down by half. And Canada's share of American lumber, those imports went from 87% to 71. So we're going down.
Ryan Miller
So here's what I want you to remember about this trade war because this is the pattern. Beat one, prices move first, inside the first year or two. Beat two, capital moves second, and it moves slower than the headlines and faster than the treaty. The Fed measured this on the China round. And the shift away from Chinese goods was one times the price change in year one and four times by year four. It starts slow and then it runs. Beat three. Governments write checks to the losers. $23 billion to farmers. I'm not saying farmers are losers. We're just talking economics here. Ottawa has $7.5 billion on the table right now, and then beat four. It ends in a deal that gives back some of the tariff and none of the plants. The Japanese plants are still in America. China's share of American imports has not come back, though. The BC sawmills, they haven't reopened. That is the pattern, my friends. Prices, then plants, then checks, then a deal that leaves the plants where they landed. So you can see the risk is that they can fix the trade deal, but does that mean a repatriation of those plants? Not always. History tells us typically not. So there are some permanent implications that can happen here. So that's why our positioning really matters in this case.
Ryan Miller
Now, clock on each beat because the timing is where the money is. Prices, a year or two. The Japanese cap rate prices on 8% over its first three years. Plants, years. The transplants took most of the decade to land. And the Fed found that the China shift was four times stronger in year four than in year one. And there's checks. One or two years. The farm money started in 2018, the year the tariffs hit. And it grew by two-thirds in 2019. Then deal. Two years or never. China got one in year two that kept most of the tariffs. Japan got an extension. Lumber is on year 40. So if you're asking when, the honest answer is this the price pain is right now. The plant money is in the next three years. The government money is the next two. And the deal is the thing you stop waiting for. And here's the common move that comes out of every trade war. In every one of those four cases, the money went to whoever owned the reroute. Not the exporter, not the importer, the person who owned the plant site, the building, the port land, the paperwork, and the bridge financing on the side of the border that the goods were moving toward. The losers were the ones who waited for the snapback. They were right that a deal came. They were wrong about what came back with it. See, spectators watch the news and react. Operators like us look at the pattern and we position.
Ryan Miller
So where does the trade war go from here? Well, I think three ways. I call it escalate, deal, and grind. In escalate, the tariffs stick and they spread. 50% on cars becomes 50% on more things. Canada answers every time. The two sides stop talking. What that looks like: more plant moves, more support money from Ottawa, more Canadian pension money staying home, more refund fights in court, and typically higher taxes to follow for those Canadian citizens. Then there's the deal. The talks come back on. They almost did in August. Ottawa's trade minister said the American demands had already come down before the talks broke. The head of economics at Macquarie said there's really no pathway to get there. Under a deal, tariffs get paused or even cut. Prices on hurt companies start to snap back. The refund trade shrinks because there is less a refund. And whoever bought companies under bad markets gets paid first. Then finally, there's the grind. Nothing big happens either way in this scenario. The 50% stays on cars and a few other things. The counter tariffs, they stay on. Nobody adds more, nobody takes any off. The annual reviews, they just come and go. This is the boring one, and it is one that most people are just not ready for because it can last four years. Lumber has been grinding for 40 years.
Ryan Miller
So here's my read. And again, hypothesis, not a forecast. The pattern says grind first, then deal. The 1981 cap was set for three years and got extended two times in 84 and in 85, and did not end until 1994. Then the Chinese got a tariff deal in January of 2020 that cut the rate on $120 billion of goods, left 25% on $250 billion. Lumber never got one. A tariff with a treaty review every July is built to be traded, but not this year, because the leverage is worth more in year two. So plan for grind, keep the deal alive on the page, and then treat escalate as the thing you buy insurance against. Picture the board. Grind is the long lease and the slow plant move. Deal is the snapback on the hurt company, and escalate is the building that fills up faster than anyone ever expected. The download has five signals for each future, so you can count on which one is arriving instead of guessing. Get three of five, and that could be your working case.
Ryan Miller
Now the sectors this trade war moves and what pattern says about each one. Let's talk about that. So Canadian Auto Parts first, because the trade war hit it the hardest, and most private equity funds own a piece of it, probably somewhere. $19 billion of cars and trucks are under a 50% tariff. A car maker will not eat 50%, and the buyer simply will not pay it. That is beat one. Prices have already moved. What the pattern says next is B2, the plants move. After 1981, the Japanese built in Ohio. Honda's Marysville plant opened in 1982. In 2018, the Chinese supply chain built in Mexico. The Canadian parts maker with a plant site in Ohio survives. The one waiting for the July review probably doesn't. Under Escalate, it moves a lot faster. Under Grind, it moves a lot slower. And under deal, it moves anyway. Because nobody unbuilds a plant. So the question for your parts company is not whether tariffs stay. It is whether it has a site south of the line and can have the cash to build on top of it. Tell me what you took from that. Here's what I took. The winner in the Canadian Auto Parts is the company that is already half American.
Ryan Miller
Industrial real estate in the American Midwest is the other side of the trade war that we can trade. A 50% tariff on Canadian cars means one thing that actually works. Build an America. Building in America is a building. It is a plant. It is the land underneath it. See, somebody owns that land. Somebody finances that building. Can you see how the economic activity can be good for the people of America? The pattern here is the Japanese transplants. Eight assembly plants and 300 facilities in a decade. That was buildings. That was land. The 1981 cap made Ohio landlords rich for a generation. The same thing is starting in the Midwest right now, and it is beat two. So it is early. Under escalate, it feels fast. Under the grind scenario, it feels steady. And under deal scenario, it cools. But a plant that moved does not move back. So the lease stays signed. So imagine this. Two managers pitched the same LP in October. One says, the trade war is bad for the economy. The other says, we own the buildings, the trade war is the feeling. Here is the lease, here is the tenant, and here is the date. Which one do you think gets the second meeting? I know I would say the second.
Ryan Miller
Hey, if you're finding value out of this discussion, could you do me a huge favor? Could you just take a second and hit that like or subscribe button? It costs you nothing, but it tells the algorithm that this is valuable information and it helps us to get it to more people. Thank you. You're incredible. Now let's get back to the show.
Ryan Miller
Canadian venture, that's another surprise. And it is one for the VCs. See, the trade war is pushing it up, not down. And here are the numbers. Canadian startups raised almost $2.7 billion in the first half of this year, up 17%. 44% went to early stage. American investors were in 28% of those deals. This hits close to home for me as I'm launching my own venture fund, Darqside Ventures. See, that is beat three arriving, the checks. The Canadian venture industry asked Ottawa on August 24th for four things. Launch the $1 billion fund of funds that is already in the budget, add a $750 million direct investment program, copy the American tax breaks on investing in startup equity, and count foreign money toward defense offset rules. So typically, when a government is being hit on trade, it spends to keep its champions home. Washington did it with farmers. Ottawa will do it with startups. So here's the split inside it. Software cannot be tariffed. There is no tariff on a login. See, a Canadian software startup with American customers is in a policy tailwind with no tariff on the product. A Canadian hardware startup that ships to American factories is the same tailwind with a 50% tariff on the product. Same country, same investor base, but different businesses. Fund the product and not the pitch.
Ryan Miller
What this means to you guys is if you run a venture fund, Canada is not a risk story right now, in my opinion. It is a policy story. A billion dollars is about to go into Canadian venture funds. Think about that. Somebody manages that money. Somebody is the first call when it lands. And American farm and dairy exporters, they took the September 8th hit. And this is where the pattern goes the coldest. Canada's counter-tariffs named dairy and farm equipment on purpose. Those are the swing state goods. In 2018, the same thing happened with China and soybeans, and Washington wrote $23 billion of checks. So beat three is coming here too. The check is coming, but the check comes after the pain, not before it, unfortunately. So what would you do? You run a private credit fund. A farm equipment maker in Iowa is your portfolio. 40% of its sales go to Canada. Canadian farmers can buy from Europe, and you cannot move a dealer network in a year. This is not a company to sell. This is a company to bridge. Six months of secured money, price for the risk, with a plan to find the next dealer network. The pattern says check from Washington arrives inside two years. You are lending across the gap until it does.
Ryan Miller
And then there is the one industry that wins under all scenarios escalate, deal, and grind, and almost nobody talks about it. The border itself. Every tariff needs a form. Every counter tariff needs a lawyer. Every refund needs a filing. Every plant move needs a truck, a broker, and a warehouse. Customs brokers, trade compliance software, cross-border freight, bonded warehouses. See when the rules change every month, the people who read the rules get paid every month. And there is a hundred billion dollars of refunds sitting in a customs computer system that has to be filed for, claim by claim. Notice what kind of company that is. Recurring revenue, sticky customers, no factory, that is the profile private equity pays the highest premium for in any market. And in this market, it also happens to be the safest seat in the house. So when the whole field is arguing about who wins the fight, by the people selling the tickets. One more trade war sector, and it is one the Canadian managers need to hear. Canadian capital coming home for the trade war. $373 billion of Canadian pension money sits under the United States. The big Ontario fund is 55% American. The federal employees fund is $41. So when those funds pull one point back across the border, that is billions looking for a Canadian home. But where does it go?
Ryan Miller
Well, the pattern says it goes where the government is already pointing. Ottawa is pointing at ports, at rail, at housing, at energy, and at the fund of funds. Typically, when a country gets hit on trade, its own institutions turn inward and its government tells them where to look. That is a private credit story and an infrastructure story. And it is a Canadian one. So if you raise from Canadian LPs, this is the meeting you set for in October. Not to ask for money, to show them the map of where their money is about to go. And here's the objection to positioning on the trade war pattern. And I know it is sitting in your head. Ryan, the pattern is four cases. Four. That is not a law of nature. I get it. That's fair. It is not. And here's why that matters to you, anyways. You are not betting the fund on the pattern. You're betting on the one thing all four cases can agree on. Capital moves towards the reroute and it does not move back. That held in 1930 when the trade collapsed. It held in 1981 when the trade grew. It held in 2018 with a deal and in lumber with no deal. It is the only part of the pattern that does not care which future arrives. So that is the part you can position on. The second objection, this time is different. There is a treaty review every July. That changes the game, Ryan. Well, maybe. Here's the counter to that. 1981 had a three-year cap that ran until 1994. 2018 had a deal in a year or two that left 25% on $250 billion of goods. A review date is not a deal. It is a date that leverage gets priced again. And if anything, it makes the grind scenario more likely, not less. Because the leverage is worth more held than it is spent. So the bottom line is this you do not need to know which future you need to own the thing every future rewards. Here are the trade war moves by asset class.
Ryan Miller
So I want to give you the trade war moves by asset class. Private equity first, then venture, because those are the two this event probably is going to hit the hardest. So private equity. The starter move, go through every portfolio company this week and answer one question for each one. Which side of the border does its money cross? And does it have a site on the other side? Then the pro move for every company that does not name the shortest path to one. A plant lease in Ohio, a supplier in Michigan, a price change that holds. That is your value creation plan for the next year. So when you sell that company, that plan is what the buyer pays for. Nobody pays for your view on tariffs. And one more for the buyers that are listening. The pattern says the deal comes, and when it comes, the hurt companies snap back first. In 2018, the companies marked down on the tariff headline and bought that year were the trade of the cycle. Beat four pays the manager who bought in beat one. Buy good companies under bad marks. Rewrite them for the grind scenario. Get paid under the deal scenario. Can you see how that works? So I want you to picture this a Canadian packaging company in your fund, 60% of sales go to Michigan. You do three things in 12 months. You sign a lease on a small plant in, say, Michigan. You move two suppliers, you win Ottawa support money. Same company, same product, same people. Now it is half American with a government. Check behind it. You did not predict a thing. You moved and positioned a company to where the pattern says the money goes.
Ryan Miller
Then there's venture funds. Here is your move. The starter move, sort your Canadian and cross-border companies into two piles. The first pile is where tariffs can touch the product. And the second is the ones where tariffs cannot. Now, the pro move here is get in front of the policy money. The $1 billion fund of funds is budgeted. When it launches, it will pick managers. Managers with a written dated view of the trade war will be easier for them to pick than the managers with another hot take. You want to be the manager with the documentation and the plan.
Ryan Miller
Now I want you to look at real estate. The starter move here is you want to map every industrial asset within a day's drive of the border crossing, both sides. Then look at the tenants, not the buildings. A building is only as good as the company paying the rent. So the pro move, be the calm landlord. The plant that moves needs a building in months, not years. The manager with the building ready signs the lease. And on the Canadian side, watch the ports. Ottawa said its trade deals reach one and a half billion consumers. Every one is reached through a port. Somebody owns the land next to it. Then you can cast your gaze on private credit. The starter move here, if that's you, write a one-page term sheet for a tariff bridge loan, six to twelve months, secure. For companies with cash and a reroute plan that got hit on the headline. See, those phone calls started the day September 8th landed. Have it on your desk this week. And then the pro move, the refund side. About $100 billion of tariff refunds are still owed as of June 29th. See, funds have been lending against those claims at about half their value, with interest added to the loan. That is a real structure being done right now. And the reported terms are in the download.
Ryan Miller
Then if you're in crypto and fintech, one line, because the data is thin and I will not pretend otherwise. When two currencies get a little jumpy, the rails that move money across border, they get busy. See payment companies, settlement companies, stablecoin rails. There is no tariff on a transfer. Treat that as a hypothesis until you see the volumes. A hypothesis with a date is still a position. A hypothesis without one is just another hot take.
Ryan Miller
Then family offices. And I know you're listening to the show. One word for you. Patience is your edge. Every move on the board scares a fund with a five-year clock. You guys don't have one. The reroute takes a decade. Look at the building, the port land, the Canadian companies under the bad mark. Buy for the decade and let the six moves come to you.
Ryan Miller
And here is the trade war watch list. The trend lines, the headlines are lagging, the trend line that the headlines are lagging is this. Money is moving from the companies that need the border to the companies that simply do not. Six places to watch it and move. The first one, September 8th aftermath. Canada's counter tariffs are live. Watch the exporter announcements, plant moves, layoffs, new financing. Everyone is a company telling you in public, for free, which pattern is there to beat. Then there's two, the Federal Circuit. About $11 billion of refunds are in front of it. Appealed on June 2nd. No date. Watch the trade court docket and the law firm alerts. They publish the same afternoon. When the ruling lands, the refund trade reprices the very same day. Then there's three. CAPE. Phase three. The customs computer system that pays the refunds. The last wave of the money was due late July and is still pending. Watch the customs status reports. When it opens, the money moves. Then four, Ottawa's money. $7.5 billion in support, plus the venture fund of funds. Watch for who rules and who qualifies. The day they publish, beat three has arrived and a lot of companies change overnight. Then five, the pension reports. Canada's biggest fund has $373 billion in the United States. Watch the American percentage. When it drops a point, billions start to move. Then there's six. July 1st, every year, the annual review of the North American deal. Put it in your calendar right now. It is the one date that can flip grind into escalate or deal in a single afternoon. So you want to be ready for whatever scenario happens every single year.
Ryan Miller
And the rule for every one of those six when a move lands, you do not react to the headline. You ask what beat of the pattern it is. And you check against the futures on the page. Prices, plants, checks, the deal. Then you move the portfolio, not the opinion.
Ryan Miller
So what's cool is everything in this trade war episode is in a tool called The Position Map, link in the notes. It has the six moves with sources and dates, three futures, each with five signals you tick to see which one is arriving. If then cards by sector, a go-a-no go matrix by asset class, and a seven question scorecard for any deal in your portfolio with a worked example. So you can put a number on every company before the next move lands. It does not tell you what to do. It does not predict anything. It gives you the pattern and a written record of where you stood with a date stamped on it.
Ryan Miller
And if you want to do this work next to people who are raising at the highest levels, then my community, the Fund Raise Capital community, is where that happens. Weekly live sessions with me, frameworks, playbooks, fund managers from around the world. The apply link is also in the notes.
Ryan Miller
So let's bring it home. 50% on cars going south, 50% on farm gear going north. A trade deal reviewed every July until 2036. 100 billion in refunds stuck in line. Four times in a hundred years this has happened. And four times it ran the exact same way. Prices, then plants, then checks, then a deal that leaves the plants right where they landed. The money went to whoever owned the reroute. The price pain is now. The plant money is the next three years. So own the plant site, the building, the port, the paperwork, and the bridge loan on the side the goods are moving to. Plan for grind, keep the deal on the page, and ensure against an escalate scenario. Six moves to watch, and July 1st is in your calendar every year. That is a fund manager who is ready and not rattled. You do these things, and you too will be well on your way in your pursuit of Making Billions.
Connect with Ryan Miller: Website | LinkedIn | Instagram